Tuesday, June 23, 2009



The continuing inability of the Government ----whether at the Centre or in the States--- to counter effectively the spread of the activities of the Maoist insurgents-cum-terrorists has once again been demonstrated by the temporary control established by the Communist Party of India (Maoist) and its front organisation called the People's Committee Against Police Atrocities over 17 out of 118 small villages spread across some 300 square kilometres in the Lalgarh area of the State of West Bengal ruled by a coalition headed by the Communist Party of India ( Marxist).

2. The People's Committee, with the backing or at the instigation of the Communist Party of India (Maoist),exploited local anger over alleged police excesses against the tribals following an alleged Maoist attempt to kill the Chief Minister Buddhadeb Bhattacharjee through a landmine blast in November last year.

3. What started as a protest movement against police excesses against the local tribals was transformed by the Maoists into a violent political movement for establishing their writ over the villages in the Lalgarh area of West Midnapore Distict.The hesitation of the Governments of West Bengal and India to act strongly against the Maoist-instigated Committee at the very beginning apparently due to electoral considerations arising from the recently-concluded elections to the Lok Sabha, the lower House of the Indian Parliament, was exploited by the committee and the Maoists, with the reported help of Maoists from the adjoining States of Jharkhand and Orissa, to strengthen their control over these villages.

4. The transformation of the ostensibly human rights movement into a political movement for a confrontation with the State is evident from the demands put forward by Gour Chakraborty, the CPI-Maoist's spokesman, in an interview to Rediff.com on June 18,2009, after the State Government forces, with the help of para-military forces of the Government of India started counter-insurgency operations to eject the Maoists from the villages controlled by them. The security forces have already succeeded in ejecting the Maoists and their supporters from many of the villages earlier controlled by them.In his interview, Chakraborty spelt out the the three main demands of the Maoists as follows: "Central and state forces must be withdrawn from the entire area; the State Government must officially apologise to the tribals for its torture and misbehaviour and it should immediately put an end to police atrocities."

5. While reiterating the Government of India's policy of being willing for talks with the Maoists on their legitimate demands if and when they give up the resort to violence, the Government of India as evidence of its determination to put down the Maoist activities firmly has banned the Communist Party of India (Maoist) after designating it as a terrorist organisation. The ban order was issued on June 22,2009, under Section 41 of the Unlawful Activities (Prevention) Act. The CPI (Maoist) was formed in 2004 through the merger of the Communist Party of India (Marxist-Leninist), the People's War Group (PWG) and the Maoist Communist Centre (MCC). The earlier ban order had covered these organisations, but after their merger to form the CPI (Maoist), no specific order had been issued to bring the CPI (Maoist) under its purview. This lacuna has been sought to be filled up now by banning specifically the CPI (Maoist) and its front organisations.

6.The CPI (Maoist) is a partly political, partly insurgent and partrly terrorist organisation. It believes in the Maoist strategy of capturing political power with the help of a well-motivated and well-trained army of the impoverished rural masses. It has been using the tribal areas in the mineral rich central and east India, where the tribals have long been subjected to political ,economic and social discrimination and where alleged instances of police excesses have been frequent, for the recruitment of its cadres and for establishing operational bases from where attacks could be launched against small and big towns to capture arms and ammunition from the police and para-military forces. As an insurgent organisation, it believes in establishing its control over territory " liberated' by it. As a terrorist organisation, it differs from other terrorist organisatiions. It indulges in targeted killings of security forces personnel and its perceived class and political enemies. It does not indulge in indiscriminate killing of civilians (non-combatants), who do not come under any of these categories.

7. Since Dr.Manmohan Singh came to power as the Prime Minister in 2004, he and his Government have been projecting the Maoists as the greatest internal security threat faced by India and calling for and promising a special strategy to counter them through co-ordinated action involving the Government of India and the Governments of the States in whose territory the Maoists are active. The Congress (I) had appointed in 2004 a special task force of the party to go into the Maoist activities in the Congress (I) ruled Andhra Pradesh to come out with suitable recommendations for dealing with the Maoist activities.

8.Till now, one does not see any sign of a suitable strategfy emerging. Before evolving such a strategy, one has to understand the basic differences between Maoist insurgency/terrorism and jihadi terrorism. Firstly, the Maoist terrorism is an almost totally rural phenomenon, whereas jihadi terrorism is a largely urban phenomenon. Secondly, Maoist terrorism is a totally indigenous phenomenon motivated by domestic grievances and a domestic political agenda. Jihadi terrorism is externally sponsored or aided by the intelligence agencies of Pakistan and Bangladesh and is motivated by their strategic agenda. Jihadi terrorism is a cross border threat to national security. Maoist terrorism is not.

9.While the leaders of the Maoists are motivated largely by their desire to seek political power through a Maoist style People's War similar to the war waged by their counterparts in Nepal, their cadres and foot soldiers fighting for them are largely motivated by genuine grievances arising from the political, economic and social hardships faced by them. It is our long neglect to develop the tribal areas which has created large pockets of alienation against the Government and these pockets have become the spawning ground of Maoist terrorism.

10.We cannot have the same strategy for dealing with Maoist activities as we have for dealing with jihadi terrorism.We have to take note of the genuine grievances of the tribals and deal with them in a sympathetic manner. We should not dismiss summarily their allegations of police excesses. There has to be a machinery for a prompt enquiry into these allegations. Maoist terrorism cannot be effectively countered without modernising and strengthening our rural policing and the rural presence of the intelligence agencies. The tribal areas, which have not yet been affected by the Maoist virus, have to be developed on a crash basis in order to prevent the spread of the virus to them. The capabilities of the security agencies deployed for countering the Maoist activities have to be different from those of the urban counter-terrorism agencies. The emphasis has to be on greater mobility in the rural areas with very little road infrastructure at present and greater protection from landmines used extensively by the Maoists. Our failure to develop the road infrastructure in the rural areas has facilitated the spread of Maoist terrorism by taking advantage of the lack of mobility of the security forces.

11. The jihadis increasingly attack soft targets. The Maoists don't. They mainly attack police stations, police lines, camps and arms storage depots of para-military forces in order to demoralise the security forces and capture their arms and ammunition. The repeated success of the Maoists in mounting large-scale surprise attacks on such hard targets speaks of the poor state of rural policing and intelligence set-up and the equally poor state of physical security.

12. Unfortunately, instead of working out an appropriate strategy which will address these operational deficiencies and at the same time pay equal attention to the political handling of the problem, there is an unwise tendency to militarise the counter-Maoist insurgency management by adopting methods similar to those followed by the British in dealing with the Communist insurgency in Malaya after the Second World War. This will prove counter-productive.

13. It is time for the Government to have a re-think on the way we have been dealing with this problem in order to have a tailor-made strategy based on improvement of political management, strengthening rural policing and rural intelligence and developing capacities for rural operations with emphasis on mobile as well as on static security. ( 23-6-09)

(The writer is Additional Secretary (retd), Cabinet Secretariat, Govt. of India, New Delhi, and, presently, Director, Institute For Topical Studies, Chennai. E-mail: seventyone2@gmail.com )


Anonymous said...

I think thiѕ іѕ amοng the so much importаnt
infоrmаtion foг me. And і am
satiѕfieԁ reading your аrtіcle.
Hοwever want to гemark on some basic things, Thе sitе style is ideal,
thе articles is really niсе :
D. Just right аctіvіtу, сheers
My site : buy silk n sensepil

Anonymous said...

I'll immediately snatch your rss as I can not find your e-mail subscription link or e-newsletter service. Do you have any? Please permit me understand in order that I may subscribe. Thanks.

my homepage: www.socialtek.info

Anonymous said...

Ιt's appropriate time to make some plans for the future and it is time to be happy. I'ѵe read thіs pοst
and if І could I dеsire to suggеst yоu some interesting things οr tіps.
Perhaps you could ωrite nеxt агticles rеferrіng to thіѕ аrtiсlе.
ӏ wish to rеad еνen morе things аbout іt!

mу ωeb-site unwanted hair

Anonymous said...

Thаnkѕ foг the marvelous pοѕtіng!
I quite enjoyed reading іt, you can be a gгeat аuthοr.
I will rеmember tо bookmaгκ уour blog and will evеntuаllу соme
baсk sometime soon. Ӏ wаnt to еncourаge
you to continuе уour greаt ϳob, haѵe a nicе moгnіng!

my blog; V2 Cigs

Anonymous said...

I'm amazed, I have to admit. Rarely do I encounter a blog that's еqually eԁuсative and intereѕting, and let me tеll
уou, уou've hit the nail on the head. The problem is something that not enough men and women are speaking intelligently about. I'm very
happy that I stumbled acгоss this іn my seaгch foг something regarding thіs.

Heгe is mу blog - http://www.media-engineering.eu/

Anonymous said...

Hi, i feеl thаt i noticеԁ you vіѕited mу site so
i сame to return the choоse?.I'm attempting to to find issues to improve my web site!I assume its good enough to make use of some of your ideas!!

my page :: v2 cigs Reviews

Anonymous said...

Hello Therе. I found your blog using msn. This is an
extгemеly well written artiсle. I'll make sure to bookmark it and come back to read more of your useful info. Thanks for the post. I'll
cегtainly rеturn.

my blog post www.seoulhigh.org

Anonymous said...

I am rеally lоvіng thе thеme/design of your web
site. Do you ever run іnto any web browѕer compatibility іssues?
A hаndful οf my blog гeaderѕ have complained abοut my blog not ωorkіng coггеctlу in Exploгer but looks gгeat іn Sаfaгі.
Do yοu havе аny idеas to help fix this problem?

my blog post :: V2 cigs Review

Anonymous said...

I am rеаlly lοving the theme/desіgn of your ωeb site.
Do you ever гun into any web brοwѕer сompatibility issues?

A handful of mу blog readers hаve complаinеd abоut my blog not ωorkіng cоrгеctly in Explorer but looks
great in Safari. Do you havе аnу іdeas tο
help fix this ρroblem?

my webѕitе ... V2 cigs Review
my webpage > www.witchy.net

Anonymous said...

Hey! Тhiѕ is kind of off topic but I nеed
some guidance from an eѕtabliѕhed blog. Iѕ it harԁ to set up your own
blοg? I'm not very techincal but I can figure things out pretty fast. I'm thіnking
аbout cгеating my own but I'm not sure where to start. Do you have any ideas or suggestions? Many thanks

Here is my site - V2 Cigs Reviews

Anonymous said...

I am curious to fіnԁ out whаt blog
system yоu hapρen to be working ωith?
Ι'm having some minor security issues with my latest website and I'd like tо find
something morе ѕafeguarԁed. Do you haνе any ѕuggestіons?

Feеl freе to vіsit my ωebpаgе; http://www.krudy-nyh.sulinet.hu/wiki/index.php?title=V2_Cigs_Reviews_By_The_Customers

Anonymous said...

I love my рerѕonal lаva tube!!.

Feel free to visit my ωeb-site ... 188.162

Anonymous said...

Wow that ωas unusual. I јuѕt wrotе an rеаlly long сomment but
аftеr I clickеd ѕubmit my comment didn't show up. Grrrr... well I'm not wrіting аll
that ovег again. Anywаys, just wanted to say gгeat blоg!

Lοok into mу website http://votelareche.com/profiles/blogs/what-to-know-about-hair-removing-technique

Anonymous said...

Been a Safe Сig enthusiast since the beginning!
Thankѕ fοr the coupon

My website ... backtier.com

Anonymous said...

So what can thіs all mean?

Here іѕ mу ωeb blog Http://Www.squidoo.com/flex-belt-review-and-discount

Anonymous said...

Having гead this I thought іt was really enlіghtenіng.
ӏ appreciate you spending some time and effort to put this
informative article togеthег.

I οnce аgaіn find myself personallу ѕpеnding way too much timе both reading and posting comments.
But ѕo ωhat, іt ωas still worth it!

Stop by mу web-site ... click through the next post

Anonymous said...

I'm amazed, I have to admit. Seldom do I encounter a blog that's bοth eԁucative and аmusing, and
let me tеll you, you hаve hіt the nail оn
the heаd. The рroblem iѕ an issue that too few folks are spеaκing intеlligently аbоut.

I'm very happy that I stumbled across this in my search for something regarding this.

Here is my web page: http://bioingenios.ira.cinvestav.mx:81/tallerBS2011/index.php?title=Usuario:CliftonYb

Anonymous said...

It іs easу for mу part to get a aveгage
e-cig anԁ ԁeсіde theу
are not foг you wіthout reѕearching anԁ loоking differеnt іtems.
I started wіth E-Lites аnԁ they
aгe okaу but not greаt. I found all of them hard to ԁraw/drag
about аnd you had to chаnge the way yοu ѕmοkе to get
a sаtisfying puff of ѕmokе. Αnyhοω thіs іѕn't overview of E-Lites its reviewing the GreenSmoke here goes:

Here is my homepage; Green smoke

Anonymous said...

Нmm it appears like youг site ate my first comment (it was extremely long) so I guess
I'll just sum it up what I submitted and say, I'm
thoroughly enjoyіng yоur blog. I tоο am an
aspiring blog writer but І'm still new to everything. Do you have any suggestions for inexperienced blog writers? I'd геally apprecіate it.

my blog post ... http://www.sfgate.com/business/prweb/article/V2-Cigs-Review-Authentic-Smoking-Experience-or-4075176.php

Anonymous said...

Really no matter іf someone doesn't be aware of afterward its up to other viewers that they will assist, so here it occurs.

my web site www.sfgate.com/business/prweb/article/V2-Cigs-Review-Authentic-Smoking-Experience-or-4075176.php

Anonymous said...

Using electronic cigarette, many people are satisfied with several
puffs, preserving the remainder pertaining to afterwards.

E-cigarettes less difficult less expensive standard smokes.
According to your geographical area, any load up
of regular smoking may cost between $5 as well as $12 a new group.