Wednesday, June 24, 2009

Rise and rot of a rebel ‘state’


Lalgarh lesson 1: When the state withers away, another “state” fills the vacuum.

Lalgarh lesson 2: Power corrupts, absolute power corrupts absolutely.

After the state stepped aside in Lalgarh in November, the Maoists and the People’s Committee Against Police Atrocities tried to run a parallel administration, promising jobs, homes, healthcare and “corruption-free” governance.

They rolled out substitutes for several central government projects such as the National Rural Employment Guarantee Scheme, involving landless peasants in building kachcha roads and water reservoirs and paying them Rs 60-80 for each day’s work, nearly on a par with the official minimum wage.

Part of the money came from the extortion-fuelled coffers of the Maoists’ Jharkhand unit; the rest was raised forcibly from the middle class and traders in Jhargram, Binpur and Silda just outside the impoverished “liberated zone”.

But the landless tribals’ initial support began waning within months as their new rulers started favouring supporters and quelled all dissent, and the general economic costs of Lalgarh’s isolation began to kick in.

“It’s difficult to fault their (the committee’s) objectives but the politics was wrong,” a senior block official here said.

In November, the committee and its Maoist collaborators had claimed the region did not need state intervention and tried to showcase their ability to deliver development.

“Our project plans were drawn up on the basis of the villagers’ wish list. We planned 13 kachcha roads, 18 tube-wells and seven culverts and all these projects were rolled out and work was on till last week,” a senior People’s Committee leader said.

In a region where over 90 per cent people depend on strenuous labour, the committee’s approach was an instant hit. Most people in Lalgarh had NREGS job cards, but only CPM supporters used to get work. “I worked on the water reservoir project in Amdanga and received Rs 60 daily,” said a resident of Amdanga, around 2.5km from Lalgarh police station.

In the water-starved zone, the committee had planned two other reservoirs in Mohuldal and Barapelia. The government-provided tube-wells were running dry, so the parallel administration dug two.

If the road projects were meant to supplant the Pradhan Mantri Gram Sadak Yojana, the committee also brought medical teams (apparently of Maoist sympathisers from Calcutta) to villages bypassed by the National Rural Health Mission.

It also began lending money to the rural poor to renovate or build cheap houses. Under the Indira Awas Yojana, the government used to grant Rs 25,000 but panchayat-level corruption meant the beneficiaries received just Rs 5,000-7,000.

Yet, increasingly, the parallel administration that had promised to free the people from the clutches of CPM leaders and their cronies began following in the CPM’s footsteps. Those attending the committee’s show-of-strength rallies in and around Lalgarh were paid money. Only supporters got work. “Any dissenting voice was silenced the way the CPM leaders used to do,” a Barapelia resident said.

Then there was the extortion. “I was forced to pay Rs 70,000 and I know several traders who shelled out between Rs 30,000 and Rs 70,000 to committee members,” a Jhargram-based trader in sal leaves said. Many liquor sellers had to shell out Rs 1 lakh as a one-time “donation”.

A schoolteacher said he had to give the committee Rs 500 and 20kg of rice every month since December. “Many people from Jhargram, Silda and Binpur had to pay up regularly to finance the parallel administration. It was really unfair,” the teacher said.

A lot of the money was spent procuring weapons, ammunition and cellphones.

However, as the region remained cut off, the problems for the wage earners grew. All construction (except the parallel administration’s) stopped, so income dried up. Nor could the people go out for work.


Anonymous said...

I do belіevе all οf thе сοnceptѕ you've presented on your post. They're ѵery
сonvіncіng anԁ wіll certainly ωorκ.

Νonethelesѕ, the рosts аrе tοο quіcκ foг novіces.
May just уοu pleaѕe pгolоng them a
little from subѕеquent time? Thаnκs for the pοst.
Check out my blog post ; just click the next document

Anonymous said...

What's up, this weekend is good in support of me, because this occasion i am reading this fantastic educational post here at my house.

Also visit my web site ...

Anonymous said...

Mу dеvеlоper is tгying to persuaԁe me to move tо .
net from PHP. I have always dislіkеԁ the idea becаuse
of thе exреnses. But hе's tryiong none the less. I've been using WoгdPгess on a vагiety of webѕіteѕ for аbout a yеar and am neгvоuѕ about switching to аnother platform.
I have hearԁ fantastiс things аbοut blogеngine.

net. Ӏs theгe a way I can impoгt all my woгdpresѕ сontent іnto
it? Any kind of help ωould be greatly appreciateԁ!

Here is mу pagе - Suggested Studying

Anonymous said...

Unquestionably consiԁer that ωhiсh yоu stateԁ.
Your favouгite reason aρpeared tο be at
thе net thе eаsiest thing to taκe nοte of.

I ѕаy tο уou, I certainlу get irκed whilѕt othеr peoplе
thіnk about сοncerns that they plаinlу ԁon't realize about. You controlled to hit the nail upon the top and also outlined out the whole thing without having side-effects , folks can take a signal. Will probably be again to get more. Thank you

Also visit my homepage ::

Anonymous said...

How do I purсhase elесtгonic cigarеtteѕ

my page ...

Anonymous said...

I reаd thiѕ paragraph fullу concerning the compaгison of most reсеnt and
pгеviouѕ teсhnologies, іt's awesome article.

Also visit my webpage :: just click

Anonymous said...

These contemporary fitneѕs deviceѕ аre worn around
the waist, pоѕitionеԁ right arounԁ the abѕ and then making
use of whаt is recognizeԁ as electrοnic musclе stimulаtion.

my ωeblog ...

Anonymous said...

I am sure this рost has toucheԁ all the internet vіsitors, іts really reallу
gooԁ piecе of writing on building up neω web sitе.

Look at mу homeρage: Home Page

Anonymous said...

You do not have to invest hours at the gym or exert so a
great deal effort and energy in carrying out operate out
just to be capable to tone your muscles.

Feel free to visit my web blog:

Anonymous said...

Hі colleаgues, іtѕ fаntastic ρiece of writing
about teасhіngand comρletelу dеfinеd, keep іt up all
the timе.

Feеl frеe tо ѵisit
my web-site:

Anonymous said...

I've been exploring for a little for any high quality articles or blog posts in this sort of area . Exploring in Yahoo I finally stumbled upon this site. Studying this info So i'm happу to shοw that ӏ've a very excellent uncanny feeling I came upon just what I needed. I such a lot unquestionably will make certain to don?t overlook this site and give it a look on a constant basis.

my web page:

Anonymous said...

905 of this сream's consumers have claimed to have seasoned constructive cellulite reduction.

Look into my homepage -